Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Issues with RSTP Interoperability and Backward Compatibility

As per Cisco RSTP is backward compatible with STP 802.1D. All the documents in Cisco specify that a RSTP enabled port will go STP when connected to an STP enabled network.

In most cases this is true. In most cases RSTP is backward compatible with STP.

http://www.cisco.com/univercd/cc/td/doc/product/metro/me3400/12225seg/3400scg/swstp.htm#wp1166519

But there is a rider to this generalized statement. RSTP is a lot more faster than STP. The typical convergence time of RSTP is less than <3secs while that of STP is about 50 seconds assuming that no proprietary cisco enhancements are used.

The rider is, RSTP and STP work perfectly together only IF RSTP is used in the core while STP is used in access-layers. Any other combination of RSTP-STP would be a disaster. IF done any other way, a STP loop would be induced into the network.

The above link gives a recommendation.. I quote
"When a network contains switches running rapid PVST+ and switches running PVST+, we recommend that the rapid-PVST+ switches and PVST+ switches be configured for different spanning-tree instances."

I have faced problems personally in RSTP-STP interoperability.

If there is need to convert a network from STP to RSTP, I would suggest that the Core is first converted to RSTP.. then the distribution and then the access. (Although this methodology is not entirely tested).

6 comments:

Dave said...

Cisco recommends working from the Access layer in towards the Distribution. http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/hw/switches/ps708/products_configuration_example09186a00807b0670.shtml
To me it made more sense to start with the core (before aware of this recommendation), but we did suffer the 50 second outage while the topology recalculated. I was wondering had we done it the other way, if the convergence time would have been less.

cheaptera said...

While actively playing planet of Warcraft, I usually purchase WOW Gold Cheap from reliable web-sites. The principal intent of getting gold from this website is, the website is trusted and provides most inexpensive WOW Gold even although in the buy wow gold cheap market.

teracheapgold said...

We know what our RS Gold customers need, so we offer the best service and best Cheap RS Gold to you. More and more players know zyy.com,more and more gamers Buy Cheap RS Gold from us. We are happy to see this, and we will continue to do well. Enjoy your game!

hugginss jetterees said...

For other handset vendors, moving away from windows 7 ultimate activation key Microsoft won't hurt their positions in mobile. Most have focused their efforts on Android, largely due to the operating windows 7 professional product key system's flexibility, popularity, and price tag (there are actually no licensing charges like with Windows Telephone). With Microsoft's acquire of Nokia, they're probably to concentrate much more on Google's operating technique.

hugginss jetterees said...

For Microsoft, though, losing Windows Phone licensees is usually a danger windows 7 ultimate activation key it's willing to take. It faces a slowing Pc industry and has struggled in tablets, which makes smartphones all the additional essential.

hou said...

We are happy to see this, and we will continue to do well. Enjoy your game!
xiaomi mi5
cheap Meizu Metal
meizu m2